There’s nothing wrong with looking but there’s plenty wrong with announcing it.
More...
Key Takeaways
- Keep your job search private until there is genuinely something worth discussing.
- Use your own device, email, telephone and personal time when searching and interviewing.
- Read your employment contract before entering the market, particularly notice, confidentiality and restraint provisions.
- Control when referees are contacted, particularly if your current employer doesn't know you're looking.
- Don't resign because somebody says an offer is coming. Make sure the next job actually exists on terms you're prepared to accept.
Your Trusted Colleague Has a Trusted Colleague
If the Company Bought the Laptop, Perhaps Don’t Use It to Escape the Company
Your Experience Belongs to You. The Client Database Doesn’t.
LinkedIn Is a Tool, Not a Flare Gun
LinkedIn has made confidential job hunting both easier and considerably more dangerous.
It is easier because recruiters can find you, vacancies are visible and professional networking can happen discreetly. It is more dangerous because some people behave so differently online the moment they decide they want another job that they might as well change their profile photograph to one of themselves standing outside the office holding a cardboard sign saying PLEASE GET ME OUT OF HERE.
Suddenly they follow fourteen recruitment agencies, connect with every recruiter between Cairns and Perth, completely rewrite a profile that hasn't changed since 2019, add thirty-seven skills and develop an extraordinary interest in posts entitled Seven Signs Your Workplace Doesn't Value You.
Then they're astonished when somebody at work notices.
Use LinkedIn, absolutely, but use it intelligently. Better still, maintain your professional profile and network throughout your career rather than desperately trying to manufacture a network three days after deciding you hate your boss.
And remember that LinkedIn is only one recruitment channel. It isn't the entire employment market. Job boards, recruiters, former colleagues, direct approaches, industry contacts, professional associations and personal networks all matter.
A good job search is targeted and deliberate. Applying indiscriminately for anything containing approximately three words from your current job title isn't a strategy. It's panic with a CV attached.
There is another trap worth knowing about because I've seen it firsthand. Some job portals allow candidates to upload a CV to a searchable database that subscribing recruiters and employers can access. That's useful because you can be found without applying for a particular vacancy, but there is a fairly obvious problem hiding in the background: your current employer might subscribe to exactly the same database.
Some platforms also identify candidates who have recently updated their CV or profile. Suddenly, the HR or recruitment team at your current employer isn't simply looking at a database of potential candidates; they're looking at you, and the system is helpfully telling them that you updated your CV last Tuesday.
Does that prove you're looking for another job? No. Is somebody likely to wonder why you suddenly polished a CV that hasn't moved for three years? Quite possibly.
So be aware of what the platform actually displays before you update anything, and be prepared for the question if somebody notices. The simplest explanation might be that this is where you keep your current CV and you recently updated it. That may be perfectly true. It may also be a convenient explanation you've prepared because announcing that you're interviewing with three competitors probably isn't your preferred alternative.
I'm not suggesting you lie to your employer. I am suggesting you understand the visibility you've created before clicking Save. A confidential job search becomes considerably less confidential when the software sends up a flare on your behalf.
References Should Help You Get the Job, Not Help Your Boss Discover You Want One
If they don't know you're considering leaving, however, allowing an enthusiastic recruiter to telephone them at 10.15 on Tuesday morning and ask whether you're any good is probably not the ideal way for them to discover your career plans.
If confidentiality matters, tell the recruiter or prospective employer explicitly. You can simply explain that your current employer isn't aware you're exploring opportunities and that you don't want them contacted unless you're the preferred candidate and you've discussed it first.
That is entirely reasonable.
Any competent recruiter should understand it immediately. If they don't, you've learned something useful about the recruiter before they've had the opportunity to learn too much about you.
The Sudden Epidemic of Dentist Appointments
Eventually, the confidential job search collides with the practical problem of interviews.
It is remarkable how many people apparently develop urgent dental problems at exactly 2.30pm shortly after applying for another job.
There is no great mystery to managing this properly. Where possible, arrange interviews before work, after work, during an appropriate break or at another mutually convenient time. If you need time away from work, take appropriate leave or make another legitimate arrangement.
You don't necessarily have to march into your manager's office and announce that you require Thursday afternoon off because you're meeting their largest competitor. Employees are allowed to have private lives and private appointments.
But privacy and dishonesty aren't the same thing.
What you shouldn't do is spend two hours being paid by your current employer while sitting in a Teams interview telling another employer how committed, trustworthy and ethical you are.
And if you absolutely insist on conducting a video interview from your current workplace, perhaps don't sit in a meeting room with your employer's enormous logo directly behind your head.
Yes, people do this.
An Interview Is Not Therapy
Eventually, somebody will ask why you're thinking about leaving.
This is where otherwise excellent candidates occasionally lose control of the aircraft.
Sometimes the real reason genuinely is your manager. Sometimes it's the culture, the CEO, the workload, lack of progression, internal politics or the fact that you've been quietly doing three people's jobs since somebody decided “operating lean” sounded impressive in an executive presentation.
You don't need to pretend everything is wonderful, but an interview isn't therapy.
If I ask why you're considering leaving and then spend ten minutes listening to you explain that your manager is an incompetent narcissist, HR is useless, the executive team couldn't organise a barbecue and everybody you've ever worked with is an idiot, I don't know any of those people.
The only person in that story sitting in front of me is you.
And I'm now wondering what you'll be saying about us in eighteen months.
A much better approach is to explain what you're moving towards rather than devoting the interview to everything you're running from. Perhaps you're looking for greater responsibility, stronger progression, larger projects, different industry exposure, better alignment with your experience or an opportunity to use capabilities your current position no longer requires.
You can be truthful about frustration without conducting a public execution of your current employer.
“They Absolutely Love You” Is Lovely. It Still Isn’t an Employment Contract.
Resign Like Someone Who Might Need These People Again
Once everything is properly agreed and it is time to resign, don't destroy years of professional credibility because you've mentally left the organisation three weeks before your body does.
Where practical, speak to your manager before your resignation starts circulating around the organisation. Then confirm it properly in writing, comply with your applicable notice requirements and work through the notice period professionally.
Do the handover properly, document what somebody else needs to know, finish whatever can reasonably be finished and return company property. Don't spend your final month wandering around the workplace explaining to everyone how much better your new company is going to be and providing unsolicited exit interviews beside the coffee machine.
Industries are considerably smaller than people imagine. Civil construction is small, mining is small, HR is small and recruitment is small. Once you've worked in an industry for long enough, the same people have an irritating habit of reappearing.
Today's former employer can become tomorrow's client, referee, contractor, recruiter, hiring manager, joint-venture partner or even your employer again.
Leave accordingly.
Where People Get It Wrong: They’re Escaping, Not Managing Their Career
The biggest mistake I see is people treating a job search as an emotional reaction rather than a considered career decision.
They have a terrible meeting on Tuesday, rewrite their CV on Wednesday and by Thursday have applied for twenty-seven positions ranging from reasonably appropriate to something involving offshore drilling despite never having seen an oil rig.
They tell colleagues they're leaving before they have anywhere to go, complain publicly about the company, take recruiter calls from the office and become so desperate to escape that the first employer offering another $15,000 suddenly looks like the greatest organisation on earth.
That isn't career management. It's an escape plan.
There is nothing wrong with deciding to leave a job. Sometimes leaving is absolutely the correct decision, and staying somewhere because you're frightened of change can do considerably more damage to a career than moving.
But once you've decided to explore the market, slow the process down enough to make a good decision.
Understand what you actually want next and, equally importantly, what you don't want again. Know roughly what your experience is worth. Research employers properly and ask questions that go beyond salary and job title. Find out why the vacancy exists, what happened to the previous incumbent, what the manager is like, how the team operates, what success looks like after six and twelve months and whether the flexibility enthusiastically advertised in the job ad survives contact with reality.
Look beyond the salary as well. Another $20,000 can become remarkably unattractive when attached to a two-hour commute, permanent availability and a manager who regards boundaries as evidence of poor commitment.
The objective isn't simply to get out of somewhere.
It's to end up somewhere better.
FAQ
1. Can I look for a job while I’m still employed?
Generally, yes. Looking for other employment is a normal part of managing a career. What matters is how you conduct the search and whether you continue complying with your employment obligations, including confidentiality requirements and any relevant contractual provisions.
2. Should I tell my manager that I’m looking?
Usually there is little reason to announce an exploratory job search. There are exceptions where people have particularly open relationships with their manager, but once you disclose that you're considering leaving, you cannot control how that information affects future decisions about you.
3. Can a prospective employer contact my current employer?
Make your expectations clear. If your current employer doesn't know you're searching, tell the recruiter or prospective employer that they shouldn't contact them without your prior approval. There is nothing unusual or unreasonable about this.
4. Should I take annual leave for an interview?
If an interview occurs during normal working hours and you cannot legitimately arrange the time another way, requesting appropriate leave may be the cleanest approach. Follow your employer's normal process and manage the absence professionally.
5. Should I accept a counteroffer?
Possibly, but start by remembering why you wanted to leave. If the issue was genuinely and exclusively remuneration and the employer corrects it, a counteroffer may deserve consideration. If the problem was leadership, culture, career progression, workload or the role itself, another $15,000 may simply make the same problem slightly better paid.
Conclusion
You are entitled to look at the market, talk to recruiters, attend interviews, compare your remuneration, consider other employers and ultimately decide that your career would be better served somewhere else. None of that requires an apology.
What it does require is a bit of judgement.
A confidential job search doesn't need an audience. It doesn't need to become workplace gossip, a sudden explosion of LinkedIn activity or a daily commentary about how much you hate your current employer. It certainly doesn't require you to resign because somebody you've spoken to twice says the new company “absolutely loves you”.
Do the search quietly and do the homework properly. Understand your obligations, protect your current employer's information, control your references, investigate the next employer just as carefully as they're investigating you and make sure the opportunity you're moving towards is actually better than the situation you're trying to leave.
Then, if you decide to go, leave properly.
Careers can last forty years or more, industries are much smaller than they look and reputations have an annoying habit of arriving somewhere before you do.
Which brings us neatly back to those two words.
If you're thinking about looking for another job while you're still employed, by all means look.
Just tell nobody until you've actually got something worth telling them.
